The First Law of Thermodynamics: Translate Work Sign Conventions
Both ΔU=Q−W and ΔU=Q+W can be correct. Identify whether work is done by or on the system before substituting.
Why do two textbooks show different signs?
Read the definition of work. With heat entering the system counted as Q>0, work done by the system gives ΔU=Q−W_by. Work done on the system gives ΔU=Q+W_on. Since W_on=−W_by, the equations describe the same energy balance.
Calculate the same process twice
A closed gas system with no mass transfer absorbs 500 J of heat and does 200 J of work while expanding. Ignore changes in macroscopic kinetic and potential energies.
- Work-by convention: Q=+500 J, W_by=+200 J; ΔU=500−200=+300 J.
- Work-on convention: Q=+500 J, W_on=−200 J; ΔU=500+(−200)=+300 J.
Remembering only “expansion means positive work” can produce the incorrect answer 700 J with the second formula. Keep the by/on label in your working.
Read each condition separately
| Condition | Direct conclusion | Not a direct conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Adiabatic | Q=0 | ΔU=0 |
| Complete cycle returning to the same state | ΔU=0 | Q and W vanish on every stage |
| Internal energy rises | ΔU>0 | Heat must have entered |
During adiabatic compression, 80 J of work done on the gas gives ΔU=+80 J despite zero heat transfer. In an ideal-gas model where internal energy depends only on temperature, an isothermal process has ΔU=0. Do not generalize that material model to every system.
Check the sign with a sentence
State the system boundary, heat direction and work direction. Then say: “The system receives 500 J as heat and transfers 200 J outward as work, gaining 300 J.” The numbers should agree with this account.
For a specific question, use its definition of work consistently when setting the signs of energy transfers.