Same Mean, Different Spread: Variance and Standard Deviation

Compare two datasets with the same mean, distinguish population and sample variance, and check the units of standard deviation.

Illustration: Same Mean, Different Spread: Variance and Standard Deviation

Does the same mean imply the same spread?

No. A mean describes the centre; spread describes how far values lie from that centre. Before calculating, establish whether the values represent an entire population or a sample used to estimate a larger population.

Treat two datasets as complete populations

Let A contain 1, 4, 7 and B contain -2, 4, 10. Both means are 4.

QuantityAB
Deviations from the mean-3, 0, 3-6, 0, 6
Sum of squared deviations1872
Population variance: divide by 3624
Population standard deviation6\sqrt6262\sqrt6

Every deviation in B is twice the corresponding deviation in A. Squaring produces a factor of four, so the variance is four times as large while the standard deviation is twice as large. Those are different statements.

Why might another formula divide by n-1?

Population variance is commonly written σ2=∑(xi−μ)2/n\sigma^2=\sum(x_i-\mu)^2/n. A common sample variance used for population estimation is s2=∑(xi−xˉ)2/(n−1)s^2=\sum(x_i-\bar x)^2/(n-1), with more than one sample value. Under that convention, the sample variances in the example would be 9 and 36.

Different denominators represent different statistical roles, so choose the convention that fits the question.

Use units as a check

If the original observations are lengths in cm, deviations are in cm, variance is in cm2\mathrm{cm^2} and standard deviation returns to cm. Variance is not directly an ordinary distance from the mean.

Adding 5 to every observation raises the mean by 5 but leaves every deviation unchanged, so variance stays the same. Multiplying all observations by 2 doubles every deviation and multiplies variance by 4. Both facts follow from the definition rather than requiring separate rules without explanation.

Questions to ask before and after calculating

Beforehand: what role do the data have, and which denominator is intended? Afterwards: are the squared deviations nonnegative, are the units correct, and does the result respond sensibly to a change of scale? Equal observations must have variance zero. A negative variance signals a calculation or formula error, not a direction of spread.

Dot plots A={1,4,7} and B={−2,4,10}, sharing mean 4 with larger spread in B.
Dot plots on the same horizontal scale: population variances are 6 for A and 24 for B.