Reaction Rate vs Equilibrium Yield: Faster Is Not More
A catalyst can help a system reach equilibrium faster without raising equilibrium yield at the same temperature and constraints.
More product sooner is not necessarily more product at equilibrium
Reaction rate asks how quickly a system changes. Equilibrium composition asks what composition is maintained at dynamic equilibrium under specified conditions. Keep observation time and system constraints explicit.
At dynamic equilibrium, forward and reverse rates are equal and macroscopic composition is constant. Reactions have not stopped, and reactant and product concentrations need not be equal. An equilibrium-constant expression belongs to a specified reaction and its stoichiometry; equal rates do not mean equal concentrations.
A catalyst changes the route and the approach
At the same temperature and system constraints, without changing the overall reaction being compared, a catalyst provides an alternative pathway and helps the system approach equilibrium faster. It does not change the reaction's equilibrium constant or, by itself, its equilibrium composition.
Compare two identical starting mixtures, A with catalyst and B without. At an early sampling time, A may contain more product. After both fully reach the same equilibrium under the same conditions, adding a catalyst does not establish a higher equilibrium yield for A. Short-time yield and equilibrium yield measure different things.
Temperature is a separate variable
Changing temperature can affect both rate and the equilibrium constant. Concentration and pressure changes require analysis of the particular reaction and constraints. Do not generalize “a catalyst does not shift equilibrium” into “anything that speeds a reaction cannot affect equilibrium.”
Check yourself: “A catalyst shifts equilibrium right because the forward reaction speeds up.” This ignores catalysis of the reverse pathway. Under the same-temperature comparison above, that is not a valid reason for a shift. Additional temperature changes or product removal must be analyzed separately.