Main Idea vs Detail Questions: Match the Scope of the Answer

A true detail may still fail as a main idea. Compare passage scope, supporting facts and overstatement.

Illustration: Main Idea vs Detail Questions: Match the Scope of the Answer

Appearing in the passage is not enough for a main idea

Original passage: a library trials longer evening hours. Most of 40 surveyed students find this convenient. The administrator recommends another two-week trial while collecting opinions from different year groups.

This is fictional practice material, not news or evidence for a real library policy.

QuestionSuitable answerBasis
How many students were surveyed?40Explicit detail
What does the administrator recommend?Extend the trial two weeks and gather broader feedbackAction detail
What is the passage mainly about?Feedback on the evening-hours trial and a recommendation for further observationWhole-passage coverage

“Forty students were surveyed” is true but misses the trial and recommendation. “All students support permanently longer hours” overstates the population, attitude and time horizon.

Cover the passage without exceeding it

Label sentence functions: background, feedback and recommendation. A main idea should connect the core information without including every number. A grander claim is not automatically better. A short trial at one library does not establish a nationwide educational-policy conclusion.

Details also have limits: 多数 means most, not all; 受访学生 means surveyed students, not every student; 建议 means a recommendation, not a completed action; 试行 means a trial, not permanent implementation.

Identify the dimension of the error

Check population, time, strength of claim and information level. Rewrite an exaggerated option into a supported statement, then decide whether it answers a detail question or the main-idea question.

This original exercise does not claim that official passages always use this structure.